Leoš Janáček’s work about a mother who loses her child under horrific circumstances gets an astute production starring Asmik Grigorian; plus, at Carnegie Hall, Gustavo Dudamel conducted a sumptuous if theatrically aimless ‘Tosca.’
By
Heidi Waleson
Nov. 18, 2026 at 3:28 pm ET
Asmik Grigorian stars in Claus Guth’s production of ‘Jenůfa.’ METROPOLITAN OPERA
Leoš Janáček’s “Jenůfa” (1904) is a grim piece, and Claus Guth’s new production, which opened on Monday at the Metropolitan Opera and runs through Dec. 4, never let you forget it. Michael Levine’s monochromatic set, James Farncombe’s bleak lighting and Gesine Völlm’s almost entirely black costumes encapsulated the rigidity of the Moravian community in which it set. It is a system so severe that its moral center, the Kostelnička (the church sextoness), commits infanticide rather than have her stepdaughter’s illegitimate pregnancy revealed.
This gloomy backdrop and Mr. Guth’s astutely detailed direction made the torments of the four principal characters all the more vivid. Jenůfa, secretly pregnant by the feckless, hard-drinking Števa, owner of the town mill, is terrified that he will not marry her. His half-brother Laca, who loves her, is so consumed with jealousy that he slashes her face with a knife to destroy the beauty that Števa admires. The proud Kostelnička, who has her own memories of a brutal, drunken husband, forbids Jenůfa and Števa’s marriage in Act 1, only to be reduced to begging for it in Act 2 after the child is born.
Asmik Grigorian, a riveting singing actress, built Jenůfa’s character arc with total commitment and believability. Her eloquent lyric soprano exuded vulnerability but never tipped into bathos. The frantic despair of Act 1 was transformed into visceral maternal instinct in Act 2, culminating in her fervently beautiful prayer for her baby’s protection; in Act 3, her somber demeanor at her wedding to Laca became the radiant maturity with which she forgives the Kostelnička.
Nina Stemme’s steely dramatic intensity made the Kostelnička’s disintegration especially shocking. Tenor Sean Panikkar fervently channeled Laca’s perpetual fury at always being discounted as well as his unswerving devotion to Jenůfa; Ryan Capozzo’s brighter tenor worked well for the shallow, vain Števa. Standouts in the smaller roles included Elena Zaremba, a severe Grandmother; Jazmine Saunders, an effervescent Jana, Jenůfa’s reading student; Erica Petrocelli, a twittery Karolka, Števa’s fiancée; and Roland Wood, sincere as the foreman of the mill. The Czech conductor Tomáš Hanus, making his company debut, deftly paced Janáček’s inventive theatrical orchestration with its striking xylophone riff and arresting passages for bassoons and solo violin.
A scene from the production. METROPOLITAN OPERA
Instead of a physical mill, the stage was enclosed in a whitewashed clapboard box with a front shutter that rose at the start of each act. The Act 1 set looked forbiddingly institutional, with beds ranged along all three sides, each with a man’s suit and hat hanging above it and a woman peeling potatoes at its foot. All ensemble movements were synchronized and ritualistic, enacting the community’s daily life as a never-ending routine—like the mill that grinds everything to powder—from which there is no exit. At times, there was too much of this ritual action, pulling focus from the psychodramas playing out in the center of the stage.
For Act 2, the bed frames were turned on end to create a cage, representing the house where the Kostelnička has hidden Jenůfa and her pregnancy. The discarded mattresses were strewn beside it and a group of black-clad women huddled in an upstage corner, occasionally advancing threateningly toward the cage, accompanied by a giant black raven. Such symbols (there was also a boy with a bloody arm who crossed the stage as Jenůfa cried out for her baby) were less trenchant than the very human moment when Jenůfa, told that her child had died, quietly folded some tiny clothes into a suitcase. Act 3 had just a few chairs and tables; the floor strewn with yellow flowers suggested the promise of spring and the wedding, but also the thaw that reveals the murdered baby beneath the ice.
Mr. Farncombe’s lighting evoked the tale’s wintry austerity. When the young women of the village arrived to sing and dance at Jenůfa’s wedding, the riotous colors of their folkloric-inspired dresses and Teresa Rotemberg’slively choreography seemed to explode onto the stage, setting up the fast-paced ending. In short order, the baby is discovered offstage, Jenůfa is accused, Laca holds the villagers at bay, the Kostelnička confesses and Jenůfa forgives her. Jenůfa and Laca then leave the community/prison, walking downstage as the shutter closes behind them.
Jonas Kaufmann, Gustavo Dudamel and the New York Philharmonic. FADI KHEIR
Recent months have featured a cascade of events celebrating Gustavo Dudamel’s first season as music director of the New York Philharmonic. Last weekend he brought the band to Carnegie Hall for a pair of concert opera performances, promised as the first installment of a five-year series. “Tosca” is not a rarity—the Met is performing it 25 times this season—but the cast featured prominent singers who have not been heard in the house in recent years.
Marina Rebeka, singing her first-ever Tosca, displayed the power and temperament required for the role. Her soprano, with its bright top notes, was clear and full, and her “Vissi d’arte” was poignant. The baritonal qualities of Jonas Kaufmann’s tenor are more present now and he had to work hard for his high notes, making his Cavaradossi solid rather than thrilling. Ludovic Tézier was nicely malevolent Scarpia. Mr. Dudamel had technicolor fun with his sumptuous orchestra, fortunately reserving his biggest fortes for non-singing moments.
However, “Tosca” is a theater piece, and having the singers wander undirected at the front of the stage felt random, even though Ms. Rebeka had a different colored gown for each act. More to the point was the highly dramatic Met performance earlier that week, which featured a serviceable Tosca from Saioa Hernández but also a gorgeously sung Cavaradossi from SeokJong Baek (especially his tragic “E lucevan le stelle”), Quinn Kelsey’s ferocious Scarpia, and the seething conducting of Oksana Lyniv.
